Best Alloy Wheel Cleaner – Bilbery vs P21s Powergel Test Review

Best Alloy Wheel Cleaner Test ReviewFor many years the German made P21s Powergel  P21s Powergel was widely regarded as one of the best alloy wheel cleaner products available. The acid free gel formula being able to cling to the wheels longer than most liquid sprays and highly effective at removing that annoying build-up of black brake dust on your alloys.

Then a couple of years ago UK company Valet Pro introduced Bilberry Wheel Cleaner which rapidly gained a large following amongst car detailers and enthusiasts alike, as a challenger to be considered as the best alloy wheel cleaner. Although not a gel formula Valet Pro Bilberry is a highly effective acid free alloy wheel cleaner which like the P21s is much safer to use on your alloys than acid based wheel cleaners.

But which one is the best alloy wheel cleaner? To find out we put both products in a head to head test on a set of alloys that had not been cleaned for over 3 months and which had not had any kind of wheel wax or sealant applied to them.

Whats-more the vehicle, a VW T4 Transporter has been used on a daily 80-mile round trip commute during the week, parked roadside and based in the countryside where the roads were a constant source of road muck and grime.

And if that was not enough for our best wheel cleaner challenge this particular T4 is an automatic so has a heavy reliance on the application of the brakes throughout the journeys.

The test was videoed with the wheel being split in two halves with low adhesion detailers tape and the valet pro bilberry alloy wheel cleaner being sprayed onto one side and the P21s onto the other.

Both were applied to the wheels dry and without the benefit of a pre-wash or soak. Both wheel cleaners were left on for 5 minutes and then jet washed off for a look at the initial results.

A soft microfibre wheel brush i.e. one without any stiff bristles was then used to get into the narrow curves between the spokes of these particular wheels followed by a final rinse with the jet wash to remove any remaining cleaner.

Which Is The Best Alloy Wheel Cleaner ?

The results of this head to head test to establish which of these two could be considered the best alloy wheel cleaner can be seen in the following short video:

Dr. Wack 1230 Wheel Rim Cleaner, 750 ml
1,090 Reviews
Dr. Wack 1230 Wheel Rim Cleaner, 750 ml
  • Quickly and automatically cleans even the most stubborn dirt such as extreme brake abrasion, oil and rubber residues as well as any road dirt.
  • Gentle on all materials and therefore completely safe to use. Even at cool temperatures, the cleaning performance remains at the highest level.
  • Thanks to the special gel formula, the cleaner stays on the rim surface for a long time, does not run off and can thus actively loosen the dirt.
  • The active indicator lets you visually see (purple to black discolouration), that the contamination is dissolved from the surface by the active cleaning components.
  • Suitable for RDKS (tyre pressure monitoring systems). Biodegradable
ValetPro Bilberry Wheel Cleaner Acid Free Wheel Cleaner 1L - Made in UK
78 Reviews
ValetPro Bilberry Wheel Cleaner Acid Free Wheel Cleaner 1L - Made in UK
  • pH balanced acid free alloy wheel cleaner for removing dirt and grime from car wheels.
  • Concentrated formula that does not need to be agitated, simply spray-on and leave for a few minutes before rinsing off.
  • Can be diluted up to 1:10 and still be effective offering excellent value.
  • Fresh scented ValetPRO wheel cleaner is three times more concentrated than competitor products.
  • Alkaline wheel cleaner is also suitable for use on painted and lacquered wheels.

4 Comments

  • Checkmate
    Posted May 8, 2014 9:23 pm 0Likes

    Naff test. Apart from inconclusive results most want to know what to do with baked on dust, not just three months of not washing. This wheel came out looking like new which was probably what it was a couple of months ago whereas my Freelander with 70k has an orange tinge to the wheels and neither of these are going to cut it.

    • Rob Mobberley
      Posted May 10, 2014 6:46 am 0Likes

      Checkmate – thank you for your comment. I can tell you a little more about the vehicle. It was a 2003 VW T4 Automatic with 18″ alloy wheels. The wheels had apparently been fitted in about 2010 and being auto did suffer quite heavily from brake dust contamination as it was used daily.

      I note you are looking for more of “how to remove caked on brake dust” type guide and review and will look to include that in the plan of future articles. Thanks again for you input – much appreciated.

      Rob

      • Checkmate
        Posted May 19, 2014 10:37 am 0Likes

        Hi Rob – sorry, was probably feeling a little despondent with the products I have tried. Having taken into account the vehicles usage perhaps I should try the product before rubbishing it! Many thanks for posting. Nigel

  • Trackback: Choosing the Best Alloy Wheel Brush for your Car Wheels

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.